# Hold Your Applause for the New Gaza Documentary

Canonical: https://brew.new/templates/substack/hold-your-applause-for-the-new-gaza-documentary

Brand: substack.com
Category: newsletter

![Preview of Hold Your Applause for the New Gaza Documentary](https://cdn.brew.new/email-preview-3f3a9a04f489fa1c-tracking_r57sx7wz6jynqrvdkqdjzj5rrh8ehavb-1789597286344.png)

## Email content

Forwarded this email? Subscribe for more

The Big ReadWednesday, 09.16.2026View in App

Upgrade to Listen

Get the whole story. Join now.Hold Your Applause for the New Gaza Documentary

There may yet be hard truths in ‘NAZA,’ including evidence of Israel’s systemic failures. But the reporting around it treats flimsy claims as proof of criminality.

Directors Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor pose with the Special Jury Award for NAZA during the closing ceremony of the 83rd Venice International Film Festival, on September 12, 2026. (Yves Herman via Reuters)

By Haviv Rettig GurPREVIEW

NAZA, a documentary by Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor, premiered at the Venice International Film Festival on September 10, won the Special Jury Prize, and reportedly received a record 25-minute standing ovation.

It has also generated a political uproar in Israel.

The title is an Israeli military acronym derived from nezek agavi, Hebrew for collateral damage. It refers to the filmmakers’ conviction that the systems Israel used to select targets and authorize strikes in Gaza enabled immoral and unlawfully high rates of civilian casualties. Their allegation goes beyond excessive tolerance of civilian casualties: They reportedly contend that the killing was intentional.

I haven’t seen the film. This means I cannot confidently assess its editing, corroboration, or the full testimony it presents. I would love to live in a world in which I could wait, watch the movie, and have a sober debate about its claims. Unfortunately, the discourse online is not so patient. That’s why it’s necessary to examine the argument its makers have published, the reporting on which it builds, and the standards by which its allegations should be judged. The film falls short on every dimension.

Start with the question of civilian casualties. The online conversation about the film—as distinct from the film’s own claims—is replete with shock and horror at the finding that the IDF calculated the estimated number of civilian deaths before each strike. According to the usual Israel critics, this shows that the resulting deaths amounted to deliberate murder...

Continue reading 'Hold Your Applause for the New Gaza Documentary'

Or

Become a paid subscriber today to enjoy unlimited access to The Free Press

Unlock the world of The Free Press and stay ahead of the curve with our premium news articles.

Annual

$8.33/month

Billed as $100 yearly

Save $20!

Monthly

$10/month

Billed monthly

SUBSCRIBE NOW

ALREADY HAVE AN ACCOUNT? SIGN IN

COMMENT

LIKE

SHARE

DOWNLOAD AS A PDF

Become a paid subscriber

Get access to our comments section, special columns like TGIF and Things Worth Remembering, tickets in advance to our live events, and more.

UPGRADE TODAY

Download on the App Store

© 2026 The Free Press

548 Market Street PMB 72296, San Francisco, CA 94104

Unsubscribe

[Open and remix this design](https://brew.new/templates/substack/hold-your-applause-for-the-new-gaza-documentary)

[Browse email designs](https://brew.new/browse/templates)